E-Procurement: A Comprehensive Overview

E-Procurement: A Comprehensive Overview

(Electronic Procurement / E-Purchasing / e-Procurement)

Key Takeaways:

• Definition and scope of the e-procurement.
• Nowadays, e-procurement work is done on digital platforms to manage sourcing, purchasing, and payments.
• It developed from early web-based tools to today’s updated, integrated cloud systems.
• Benefits of e-procurement include faster processes, lower costs, improved transparency, and better spend visibility.
• Main features: supplier management, e-catalogs, RFx tools, e-auctions, contract management, P2P automation, and analytics.
• Some challenges include system integration, user resistance, supplier readiness, security risks, and high initial investment.
• For successful implementation, it requires strategy, training, supplier onboarding, and ongoing monitoring.
• Future observation: AI, blockchain, mobile procurement, sustainability, and marketplace-driven sourcing.

Introduction

The process of carrying out the procurement processes of supply chain management with the help of digital systems like cloud-based platforms and other internet-related technology is called e-procurement. There are various tasks related to procurement that are grouped under e-procurement, which includes sourcing, processing the invoice, tenders, auctions, and solicitations. It spans from contexts that include business-to-business-to-business-to-government to business-to-people.

Automation and integration of the various processes of day-to-day organizational activity not only increase the effectiveness but also bring clarity, compliance, and strategy to the table. This article will be delving deeper into the world of e-procurement, which will include its definition, pros, cons, implementation, future, and technical advancements, as well as challenges.

Definition & Scope

While there are a number of definitions found when it comes to e-procurement, a working definition that is concise and can be used to understand the very fabric of the system is that the e-procurement system uses technology to its benefit for executing business-to-business operations of all kinds of products, materials, and services. This process is an umbrella that contains all the processes of putting forward a tender, quoting, requisitioning, and picking out the appropriate suppliers to the very end of the procedural spectrum, which contains making the purchase order, invoice, and receipt, as well as payment. As stated earlier, there are many schools of thought, and one notable among them is of the opinion that the whole system of e-procurement includes all the processes of traditional procurement, from searching for an employer to making tenders and receipts to getting payments and regularly conducting post-purchase reviews. It is often considered that e-procurement is a subcategory of traditional procurement, with the most notable addition being its dependency on the technical tools and the various digital systems.

Evolution and Historical Context

Origins and key milestones

The notion of e-procurement rose in the 1990s and was a trending phenomenon in the 2000s as well. This is because in those couple of decades the companies and businesses started taking advantage of technology under their fold, which led to the eventual rise of e-procurement. For instance, it is said that the early stages of the systems were used by companies such as IBM in the year 2000.
Research has been able to well define the three main stages of the e-procurement system, predominantly following the work of Jari Tavi:

1. Early systems consisted of tools that could be used by well-experienced professionals of procurement, thereby limiting the scope of being user-friendly.
2. The web system looked forward to supporting more users irrespective of their technical skills and providing the much-needed support to the procurement teams, but however, the system still fell short of user-friendliness and adaptability.
3. Advanced systems come with user-friendly interfaces with flexible features that can be easily adapted by the user, providing unparalleled functionality, productivity, and support. The regulations regarding public procurement have also initiated adoption of the electronic mode of communication when it comes to public tenders.

Adoption trends

It has been noted during much research that some sectors have been readily accepting the technical advancements related to e-procurement, but there are numerous sectors that are not being able to cope with the technological advancements in the sphere of e-procurement. The public sector has been readily adopting e-procurement to remove concerns regarding clarity, trust, transparency, and corruption, and it also works in line with the agendas and digital tools that the government rolls out from time to time in this regard.

Key Drivers and Benefits

What drives organizations to adopt e-procurement?

• The limitations of budget and the requirement for constant efficiency when it comes to the procedures of the supply chain market.
• Clarity and transparency are paramount when it comes to procurement, along with increasing the compliance capability and bringing more visibility into the spending pattern and analytics.
• E-procurement is required due to the complicated scenario of the global supply chain, which often requires fast and effective sourcing.
• Digital advancement and the use of technical tools of procurement and adopting them into mainstream businesses help with finance and other procedures of the overall supply chain management activities.
• To follow rules and regulations and abide by the protocols that are set in place by the government.

Core benefits

The main advantages that the business houses get by adopting e-procurement are:

• The time taken for the completion of a production cycle is comparatively reduced due to faster placement of requisition.
• E-procurement helps the business houses to reduce the number of human activities and automate them along with making them error-free.
• E-procurement helps to ensure that the business houses stay within their budget and get the most out of their spending so that they do not face any financial constraint when trying to execute supply chain procedures in the market.
• It also ensures that the business houses have good supplier relationships so that they can collaborate on various procedures together, and this mutually beneficial relationship is made possible through supplier portals tracking the performance of the suppliers and by e-auctioning.
• It has the ability to scale and integrate with ERP/financial systems. The procurement system has the capacity to examine and incorporate the financial systems with the ERP.
• Digital procurement is much coveted by the business houses because in today’s complex market scenario, this brings much-needed relief in the form of transparency and compliance, which combats corruption and also encourages healthy competition.

Challenges and Risks

With a number of benefits comes its own share of problems because there are a number of challenges that the business houses might face while incorporating and adopting e-procurement. It is found through several research studies that the public sector has found out three main problems in the domain of e-procurement. They are related to technology, organization, and the environment.

Major challenges include:

• Technological: It is often difficult to incorporate new digital systems with the already existing one that has been in place for decades, and along with it arise concerns about the quality of data, the security that comes with it, and also its capacity for being user-friendly.
• Organizational: One main factor in this case is the lack of desire for change, along with unsteady leadership and absence of training, leading to a lack of technological advancements and restricting change within the company, which leads to lesser productivity.
• Environmental/Contextual: There are a number of compliance- and regulation-related hurdles that small or medium business houses might face, such as undependable suppliers or infrastructural inefficiencies or any other cultural or geographical factors.
• There are a few more issues that often come up with e-procurement; they are:
• Initial investment cost: This includes the digital software system and the training that has to be imported, among other things.
• Reduction in personal/face-to-face supplier interactions: This too can have a negative impact on the supplier and business house relationship due to a lack of interaction.
• Security and data-privacy concerns: There can be some concerns about storing hypersensitive data about both the procurement of the company and the supplier online.
• Lack of standardization: There is an absence of standardization across various places, making international e-procurement more complicated.

Implementation failure risks

There is much research that proves that incorporating digital procurement can often backfire for many business organizations because it is found out that they often focus on the technical side but not on the supplier ecosystem and their capacity to incorporate such technological advancement, which might lead to less productivity and other major inefficiencies.

Core Components and Functionalities

Today the modern e-procurement system includes the things written below:

• Supplier management/onboarding: Registering, examining, and testing the performance of the supplier.
• Catalog/e-catalog management: The catalogs for both electrical products and electrical services, along with others.
• Sourcing / RFx / e-Auction: Accepting and processing requests for various information queries, proposal quotes, and auctions.
• Purchase-to-Pay (P2P): This begins with requisition and then goes on to approval and purchasing them to receive the product and create an invoice.
• Contract management: Apart from creating and storing, it also includes compliance checking.
• Spend analytics & dashboards: Visualizing data, analyzing the category, and also examining and putting suppliers under various categories that they fall into.
• Integration & connectivity: Connected with the ERP and external markets along with financial and supplier systems.
• Compliance, audit trail & workflow: Checking the budget along with routing approvals and checking the overall working and operations.

These various benefits help the business houses to make procurement standardized and also automatic, which not only increases the effectiveness of the organization by examining the spending patterns and the supply relationships but also helps to achieve all goals through strategy and also achieve sustainable profitability.

Implementation Approach & Best Practices

For any procurement incorporation in a company to be successful, there are a number of steps that are to be followed along with a structured approach:

Implementation stages

1. Strategy & business case – The objectives of the business houses must be clearly defined, such as reduction of cost or increasing operational speed, andthese stakeholders must be identified at the earliest.
2. Process redesign & standardization—It is essential to define the targets for e-procurement along with mapping the current processes.
3. System selection & integration – Choosing software and digital platforms that can be easily incorporated within the present finance or ERP
4. Pilot & rollout—Starting with a few categories and refining and training along with progressing in the initial process of rolling out.
5. Supplier engagement – Onboarding the suppliers so that they can carry out transactions through the system
6. Change management & training The main issue is to address the lack of interest on the part of the user as well as training the staff and stakeholders appropriately.
7. Monitoring & continuous improvement – Measuring KPIs by using dashboards and streamlining sourcing along with filtering out the supplier ways

Best practices

• It is important to encourage the senior leaders of a company to lead the initiative.
• Clearly underdetermining the goals and key performance indicators of the companies necessary
• It is important to start with categories that can give guaranteed results.
• It is important to incorporate the digital systems with the ERP to avoid breach of any security.
• It is important to be absolutely clear about the protocols of onboarding as well as the implementation of the training of the suppliers.
• It is important to look after the user experience to increase implementation and also rectify faults.
• It is important to build a governance structure that can be used to check compliance audits and overall procurement procedures.
• It is important to continuously keep an eye on the improvement, including noting and reporting the reviews of the performance of the suppliers.

Public vs. Private Sector E-Procurement: A Comparison

Emerging Trends & Future Outlook

E-procurement is constantly evolving, and there are a few shifts or trends that are notable in this sector:

• Cloud-based procurement platforms – It enables fast deployment and offers scalable measures along with a lesser initial cost.
• Artificial Intelligence (AI) and analytics—It helps to forecast spend analysis, examine the potential risk with suppliers, and also helps to reduce workload by automatization of sourcing decision-making.
• Blockchain and distributed ledger technologies (DLT)—It helps to build mutual trust by increasing clarity and preventing unethical activities in the sector of procurement.
• Marketplace-based models and aggregators—It helps to bring flexibility in sourcing various goods and services from suppliers around the world.
• Mobile procurement & supplier portals—Easier to get requisitions instantly along with approvals and an increase in supplier meetups.
• Sustainable/green procurement integration – Implementation of the environmental, social, and governance objectives in protocols into the e-procurement framework.
• Greater focus on supplier ecosystem and collaboration—It helps to transition from a merely transactional relationship with the supplier to a very strategic one.

The coming decades will witness procurement becoming more streamlined, strategic, and data-based, which will be incorporated into various categories of different business sectors, with e-procurement being its pillar of support.

FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)

Q: What is the difference between e-procurement and e-purchasing?
A: The terms are often used to replace one another, but in reality the former refers to procurement in a digital format, which covers everything from sourcing to analytics and payment, while the latter refers to the ordering process, which might include purchase order generation and requisition.
Q: Does e-procurement only apply to large organizations?
A: No. Though it is the popular perception that only large-scale industry or organizations can benefit from this, there are many mid-size and small business houses that are using cloud-based software systems to evolve their procurement operation.
Q: Can e-procurement guarantee cost savings?
A: There are various tools that are provided by procurement to make sure that all procurement operations are streamlined and efficient enough to generate profit, but e-procurement is not synonymous with profit making because to make a business profitable, governance, mutual understanding with the suppliers, and overall optimization of resources are required.
Q: What are some common metrics (KPIs) for e-procurement success?
A: The most common key performance indicators include the time taken for purchase and order cycle and the percentage of the number of suppliers that were onboarded, along with the analysis of the structure of spending and performance.
Q: How does e-procurement help with sustainability?
A: E-procurement can help to incorporate the sustainability goals of business houses into the operations of the supply chain management by tracking and maintaining supplier performance along with making sure that they are in line with the ethical labor practices and environmental protocols that are in place.
Q: What are barriers in the public sector for e-procurement?
A: With a lot of benefits comes its own share of problems, some of which are lack of interest on the part of the suppliers along with complexities regarding the regulatory processes as well as limitations due to lack of digital skills among users. Apart from these, there are also concerns on the technical and organizational front.

Conclusion

It is safe to say that e-procurement is an extreme shift in the world of traditional procurement because it involves moving away from manual labor and people-based operations to digitization of the processes of a huge part of supply chain management. It represents the fast-moving, ever-changing world, which is inclined towards digitization, technology, and strategy. If implemented correctly, then it can revamp the whole experience of the procurement procedures by optimizing the whole process of procurement and making it error-free. It helps to increase governance, reduce lead times, give insights into the spend analysis, and also find out ways to make the budget more effective and its outcome more profitable. This will, however, come only if the organization plays a major role in incorporating it in the mainstream business. There will come a time not far from now when this will be the order of the day, and traditional procurement will take a back seat because it not only reduces workload and increases efficiency but is also error-free, which promises the objective of sustainable and long-lasting profitability.

References

1. Nawi, M. N. M., Roslan, S., Salleh, N. A., Zulhumadi, F., & Harun, A. N. (2016). The benefits and challenges of e-procurement implementation: A case study of Malaysian company. International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues, 6(7S), 329–332.
2. Makerere University. Watuleke, J. (2017). E-procurement: Evolution and adoption. A review of literature. IJRDO – Journal of Educational Research, 2(5), 50–62.
3. Mohungoo, I., Brown, I., & Kabanda, S. (2020). A systematic review of implementation challenges in public e-procurement. In: Responsible Design, Implementation and Use of ICT. Springer.
4. Robaty Shirzad, S., & Bell, D. (2013). A systematic literature review of flexible e-procurement marketplace. J. Theor. Appl. Electron. Commer. Res, 8(2), 49–70.
5. Marketing91. (n.d.). What is e-procurement? Advantages and disadvantages.
6. Spendflo. (n.d.). Top 6 Benefits & Advantages of e-procurement you must know.

Author’s Bio:

Pankaj Tuteja
Head of Operations – India
https://www.dragonsourcing.com

Image: pixabay.com